How to maintain a logical sequential order (Wcag 1.3.2)

  • Web
  • Advanced

General explanation #

The purpose of WCAG 1.3.2 criterion is to ensure that, if the order of the content matters, it must be preserved regardless of how it is presented to the user. For example, if you browse with CSS disabled or when you use a screen reader.

The order of content is important if the order of the content cannot be changed without affecting its meaning.
For example, for an ordered list or a table, the order of the content is important, on the other hand for an unordered list, the reading order has no impact on the user's understanding of the content.

A WEB page can be composed of several independent sections having specific roles. The relative positions of a navigation section and a main page section generally do not affect the understanding of the page content. Whether the navigation is at the top or on the left of the screen, does not interfere with understanding, even if a reading order can be imposed within one of these sections.
There can therefore be several reading orders on a WEB page to satisfy the success criterion.

What you should not do #

Use white space to format plain text #

When presenting content, it is important not to use space characters, such as spaces, tabs, line feeds or carriage returns.
In some cases, these characters are used to format tables, or reproduce columns of data in textual content. This method is prohibited because assistive technologies will not be presented with the information in a logical reading order, so the information returned to some users will be incomprehensible.

Below are two examples that are invalid and therefore not understandable with screen readers.

Example of a blank character to format a tables #


Working hours with Classroom
 
                                                         
            Monday               Tuesday           Wednesday     

 Morning    9.30 a.m.            9.30 a.m.         8.00 a.m.
            to 1 p.m.            to 1 p.m.         to twelve o’clock     
            B201                 B201              A001

Afternoon   2 p.m                2 p.m             Break
            to 5 p.m.            to 5 p.m.
            A103                 B201

Note that the presentation above is a purely a visual formatting, but no semantic relationship can represent tabular relationships.
Assistive technologies will read the content as it appears in the code, therefore, in an illogical and incomprehensible order. Here, the solution would be to use a table or present the information in a linear maner.

Example of a blank character to separate content into two columns #

Digital accessibility aims to make possible      it is not a question of multiplying
access to digital information whatever       media, but from
the nature of the person's disability and the way     respect functional rules, graphics,
whose information everyone consults. It concerns     technical and editorial that will allow everyone
different technologies such as the Web, videos      to access information regardless of their
and Word and PDF documents, but also the      consulting tools.
digital television or mobile phones.    

The paragraph above does not conform, space characters are used to separate the text into two columns. Assistive technologies will read the text line by line which would be an illogical reading order.

Use a layout table #

Although WCAG does not prohibit the use of layout tables, it is recommended to use layout in CSS in order to maintain the semantic reading of the content. If a layout table is used, it is important that the content makes sense when linearized.

Tables present content horizontally and vertically, however an assistive technology reads this content in a linear way, the table is read from top to bottom reading the entire row before moving on to the next.

Therefore, you have to be careful when using a layout table, you have to check that the content is understandable with a screen reader.

Example of an invalid table #

The table above displays a menu, with the logo on the side.

The problem is that, with a screen reader, the reading order is changed, because, instead of stating all the menu links, the image will be vocalized in the middle of them.

Use CSS to position information #

To position content in a reading order, it is recommended to use structural markup, rather than CSS positioning properties. The latter can lead to errors, as the content can be displayed/interpreted in a different order than it is in the source code.

So, if the reading order is important, be careful, when using CSS Flexbox, grid and position, not to change the visual order of the content compared to its position in the code:

  • With CSS flexbox, avoid using the order or flex-direction:reverse property ;
  • With CSS grid, be careful about manually placing elements on the grid
  • With positioning properties, avoid detaching the visual order of elements from the order in which they appear in the DOM

If a user disables CSS, or uses a screen reader, the rendering of information will no longer be in the correct order.

Example of a position menu in CSS #

The layout below was created with CSS, if you disable the CSS, you will notice that the reading direction will be different than the one displayed.

Sports Products Football Tennis Rugby Clothes Accessories

Example of a tab where the content is positioned before #

In the example below, tabs will be displayed with content that will be positioned with flexboxes.

You are now on the Home tab.
You are now on the Profile tab.

Elements are placed with the order attribute, which is not the same display order in the DOM.
By disabling the CSS or using a screen reader, we see that the tabs are no longer before, and so after, the content of these tabs.